Manitowoc Will Run Its Own Disability Rides After Contractor Exits, With No Price Tag Yet

Assist-to-Transport is closing its Manitowoc site and cutting 39 jobs. The city plans to take over paratransit Jan. 1, after riders reported waits of up to two and a half hours, but it hasn't published what the service will cost.

Manitowoc Will Run Its Own Disability Rides After Contractor Exits, With No Price Tag Yet
Tony Webster from Minneapolis, Minnesota, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Manitowoc residents who can't use a regular bus because of a disability or health condition will ride with the city starting Jan. 1, if the plan clears the budget process, after Assist-to-Transport told the state it would permanently close its Manitowoc site and lay off 39 workers. Mayor Justin Nickels announced the takeover Nov. 3. No published account yet says what it will cost.

The Public Works Committee was scheduled to consider adding paratransit to the city's responsibilities Thursday, with city staff expecting approval, and the Finance Committee was set to take public comment on the 2027 budget at 6 p.m. the same evening in Council Chambers.

Riders Describe Long Waits

One Manitowoc man with a disability told WBAY he's used the service for six years and that problems began about six months ago. He reported one wait of two and a half hours, said waits near an hour and a half are now common, and said the delays have made him skip medical appointments and miss medication. He also worries about getting stranded in a winter that can reach 20 below. The company is "falling short of their mark, and it's discouraging," he said.

Nickels told NBC 26 that residents had complained about long waits and that some said they were never picked up. He expects a smooth change and said he hopes customer service improves because a city-run service isn't meant to turn a profit. Jacky Breech, who has ridden for about seven years, at least twice a week, to volunteer and see doctors, told the station she's concerned about the transition.

Those riders have legal protection that a contractor's exit doesn't erase. Federal rules require any public entity running fixed bus routes to offer paratransit within three-quarters of a mile of those routes, at no more than twice the regular fare, with next-day booking. The rules also bar capacity limits, including patterns of substantial late pickups or missed trips, though occasional failures don't count as violations.

A Plan Months in the Making

The city says it told the company earlier this year about rider concerns and that the contract, which has run nine years, wouldn't be renewed. It says it meant to announce the change after committee and budget review, and the company's notice came first. Nickels said in a statement that the city "has been planning for this transition for several months." The Personnel Committee reviewed positions, pay structure and the operating framework Oct. 5.

Money was part of the reasoning. Minutes of a Manitowoc County Transportation Coordinating Committee meeting dated April 29 record that Derek Muench, Sheboygan's director of parking and transit, came to explain how that city brought paratransit in-house. Manitowoc was looking at the idea "for financial reasons as well as to safeguard themselves from private providers pulling out," the minutes say. By November, the provider was pulling out.

Kevin Bottesi, Maritime Metro Transit's division manager, told Seehafer News the aim is to "provide better service, responsibly manage public resources" and give the city more accountability. Maritime Metro, which has offered ADA paratransit since 1992 through a local contractor, is itself a former private company. The city took over the Manitowoc Motor Coach Company in January 1978.

What Taxpayers and Workers Don't Know Yet

Federal numbers show how expensive this service is to run. In 2023, Federal Transit Administration data put Manitowoc's contracted demand-response service at 10,373 trips and $541,729 in operating costs, or about $52 a ride. Its buses carried 215,214 trips for $1.76 million, about $8 a ride. Those figures are three years old and cover a contracted service, and the city hasn't said how its own costs would compare.

City officials have said they expect to add a mix of full-time and part-time positions, without saying how many or what they'll pay. Published accounts don't say whether Assist-to-Transport's drivers will get first shot at those jobs. The company, which also goes by Student Transportation of America, reported 39 layoffs by Jan. 1, though the city says that number likely reflects work beyond the Manitowoc contract.

The new costs land in a budget that already leans on borrowing. Nickels has said 2027 could be the first budget of his tenure in which the city takes on more debt than it pays off, and employee health insurance on the city plan is budgeted to rise 13%. The city says details on operations, jobs and rider information will come once the budget is final.

https://manitowoccountywi.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/4-29-2026-Transportation-Coordinating-Commitee-Minutes.pdf

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.

Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.

You've successfully subscribed to Fox Watershed.

Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.

Success! Your billing info has been updated.

Your billing was not updated.