Baldwin's Medicare for All record points to Van Hollen, not Schumer

Tammy Baldwin cosponsors Medicare for All. Chris Van Hollen does too. Chuck Schumer doesn't. Her Dec. 1 leadership vote should go to the candidate who shares her bill.

Baldwin's Medicare for All record points to Van Hollen, not Schumer

Sen. Tammy Baldwin, D-Wis., is an original cosponsor of the Medicare for All Act, Sen. Bernie Sanders' bill to move the country to a single public health plan. On Dec. 1 she'll help choose who leads the Senate's new Democratic majority, and she has already said she'll vote for Chuck Schumer, a leader National Nurses United points out never cosponsored that bill. His challenger, Sen. Chris Van Hollen, D-Md., did. Baldwin should vote for him.

Baldwin's reasoning deserves a fair hearing. In a Nov. 12 statement, she pointed to the Brewers' record season and said next year "is not the time to change our management," crediting Schumer with at least 55 Democratic seats, the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel reported. Schumer recruited many of the party's winning candidates and raised money for them, according to The Associated Press, and he has laid out a 100-day agenda that includes health care legislation. Their history goes back a decade. Schumer named Baldwin secretary of the Senate Democratic caucus in 2016, the post that first put her in party leadership.

The seats weren't Schumer's

Baldwin's case rests on giving Schumer credit for the majority. The record doesn't support that, an argument The New Republic's Alex Shephard laid out Nov. 11 and the results bear out:

Schumer does get some credit. Shephard wrote that he played an important role in some pickups, including recruiting Colom and persuading former Sen. Sherrod Brown to run in Ohio, and Colom told Bloomberg Government that Schumer helped with fundraising. A leader who helped is still a long way from a leader who earned the gavel.

Her own bill points to Van Hollen

Medicare for All isn't a side issue for Baldwin. She signed on to Sanders' bill in 2017 and wrote at the time that universal coverage must be the goal, and she was back on the cosponsor list when Sanders reintroduced it April 29, 2025. Van Hollen came later. He joined the bill in November 2025 and posted on Dec. 1, 2025, as enhanced Affordable Care Act tax credits were running out, that "We need Medicare for All." Before that, his own Senate page says, he backed a Medicare public option as a step toward it.

Health care is the fight Baldwin picked for herself after the election. Her first bill of the new term, the Medicare at 50 Act, would let people ages 50 to 64 buy into Medicare. After those subsidies lapsed, her office said, marketplace premiums for that age group doubled in 2026 while their enrollment fell 6%, and she said Wisconsin families "sent an unmistakable message" at the polls. One of the nine Democrats who signed on with her that day was Van Hollen.

The gap between public Medicare and private coverage already shapes who gets help in Wisconsin. Reported in October, President Donald Trump's one-time $90 Medicare checks skipped anyone on a private Medicare Advantage plan, which covers most of the state's Medicare enrollees. A majority leader who has put his name on single-payer would be a stronger partner for a Wisconsin senator trying to close that gap.

Trump's $90 Medicare Checks Skip Most Wisconsin Enrollees
Medicare Advantage enrollees, 56% of Wisconsin's Medicare population, won't get the $90 Part B rebate. Here's who qualifies and when it arrives.

Since Nov. 12, Van Hollen has picked up Sanders, Sen. Jeff Merkley and incoming senators El-Sayed and Flanagan, according to the whip count The New Republic cited. National Nurses United, the Machinists union and the Office and Professional Employees union have endorsed him too, and the Cap Times editorial board in Madison urged Baldwin on Nov. 18 to reconsider.

Van Hollen is the underdog, and he says so himself. The same whip count, compiled by the Progressive Change Campaign Committee, a Van Hollen ally, listed 15 senators firmly with Schumer and five with Van Hollen, with most of the caucus uncommitted. Senate Democrats vote by closed, secret ballot on Dec. 1, and the winner needs 28 votes. Baldwin can still back the candidate who shares her bill. She should.

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.

Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.

You've successfully subscribed to Fox Watershed.

Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.

Success! Your billing info has been updated.

Your billing was not updated.